Tuesday, August 30, 2011

Gov’t urged to stop construction of coal power plant in Subic

ANDREO CALONZO, GMA News

Representatives of various sectors on Tuesday urged the government to stop the construction of a coal power plant at the Subic Bay Freeport zone in Zambales for allegedly posing threats to health, tourism, and the environment.

Energy giants Manila Electric Co. (Meralco), Aboitiz Power and Taiwan Cogen Corporation are currently building a 600-megawatt coal power plant in Subic, which is estimated to cost $1.28 billion.

The plant, which will reportedly start operating in 2014, will supposedly bring cheap energy and augment energy needs of the area and the rest of Luzon.

Akbayan party-list Rep. Walden Bello urged the Department of Environment and Natural Resources (DENR) to recall the environmental compliance certificate (ECC) earlier issued by former Environment chief Lito Atienza for the plant’s construction and operation.

“It [The ECC] was very quietly done. Did they really conduct a good assessment in terms of public health and environmental impacts? Was it a clean deal?... Bakit walang public consultation? Napakahalaga sa isang ECC na may public consultation," Bello claimed.

Bello, describing coal as the “dirtiest energy source," wondered why the previous administration allowed the construction of the coal power plant.

"‘Yung environmental aspects, kung hindi [maayos], talagang hindi dapat bigyan ng go-signal ‘yan… If it doesn’t pass environmental standards, then it can’t go on," he said in a press briefing on Tuesday.

No supporters

Bello, who filed last June a resolution to conduct a probe on the issuance of the ECC, likewise said the construction of the coal power plant in Subic “has no supporters from the public and government officials" in the area.

“If we have this kind of opposition from the people and from a unified force, including the governor, malaking factor ito. Will the power companies push through a plan that will be constantly opposed by the people? Malaking risk ‘yan para sa kanila," he said.

Meanwhile, Alex Hermoso, convenor of the Subic Bay Coalition against Coal, said the coal power plant was not needed because the energy needs of the province were already being met by existing plants.

“Hindi naman bumababa ang kuryente kahit na may surplus tayo. Lagi sinisingil sa taumbayan," he said during the same press conference.

He added that the government can instead tap renewable energy sources, such solar energy and wind turbines, if it really wants to augment the power supply in the country.

Gregorio Magdaraog, vice president for corporate affairs of the Ocean Adventure marine park in Subic, likewise expressed reservations on the plan to build the coal power plant.

“Kami po ay nangangamba na ang proyektong ito ay magkakaroon ng negative effects sa aming kalagayan sa Subic. Ang amin pong kalagayan bilang pasilidad na panturismo ay maaring magkaroon ng hindi magandang epekto dahil sa power plant na ito," he said. - VVP, GMA News


Showing 20 of 32 comments

  • Subic Bulletin
    Lets just be clear on one important issue here. This debate is not about how clean or dirty the coal plant will be. The cleanest statistics still show the plant emitting pollution levels too high for the community in Subic Bay to accept. All the "Clean Coal" marketing hype has...
    show more
  • noypi_07
    PH is a country ran entirely by "bureaucrats". Ito ang isang dahilan kaya napakabagal ng paglago natin as a nation. I say let the "technocrats" do their job and when they say a plant is safe and in compliance, then you "bureaucrats" need to concur and support them.
    Mr Bello,...
    show more
  • joeldcndcn
    there are Ph certified mechanical engineers who are authorized to examine & declare when any power generating plant
    ( diesel, nuclear, coal fired, hydro ) is not environmentally friendly, ok? all other professions even a lawyer do not have such authority and can be sued in court for usurpation of...
    show more
  • Subic Bulletin
    There are also authorized smoke testing centers all over thePhilippines that must be attended before registering your car but how many trucks and buses belch out clouds of smoke right in your face? Who is accountable for this? Who enforces this? Why would a power plant be any different?...
    show more
  • Bkt pinipilit nila yang coal plant eh kht advance na ang tech nyan eh nagccost cutting parin ang mga mayari about the cleaning nila.

    Buti pa wag nlng ipatayo.
  • dapat titigl 'yan... renewables is the d way forward.
  • Newer design, modern technology and integration of pollution control equipment will make a coal power plant less pollutant nowadays.

    Renewable energy sources such as solar and wind turbines have far less generation capacity compared to a coal power plant.

    Development has its trade-offs. PHL should not be left behind because...
    show more
  • Subic Bulletin
    Ryan, you said it: "they are less pollutant" but this is still unacceptable to the community in Subic. We don't want any pollution, more or less who cares we want NONE.
    If the Philippines needs Coal Power to advance then there is no hope for us because the rest of...
    show more
  • First, there's no such thing as a non-pollutant energy source. Even solar power is contributing some pollutant from its storage batteries which are Ni-Cad.

    Second, developed countries can afford to build costly renewable energy sources because they now have the money realized from running their industries using those non-renewable sources...
    show more
  • noypi_07
    I say build the coal plant someplace else, put a cap on power supplied to Subic, and when it's not enough after 5 years, isampal sa mukha nung magreklamo etong resolution ni Bello, lalo na dun sa mga taga-Ocean adventure.
  • this is just not a resolution by Rep. Bello but the whole Zambales Province. so shut the f**k up. the people of Zambales and Olongapo are against it. If you're not from Zambales or Olongapo, wag ka nalang magsalita. Harapin mo si Rep. Bello at kausapin mo siya ng harap...
    show more
  • noypi_07
    read again pls, didn't I said build the coal plant someplace else?

    I am also a citizen of this democratic country who have the same right as you to comment, especially that there's a looming power crisis which would eventually affect PH economy.

    Ang pagkakaron ng Pro at Kontra sa...
    show more
  • Coal Plant is not the answer in the looming power crisis. Coal Fired Power Plant is an outdated technology. There is no such thing as Clean Coal.


    Yes, you said that it should be built somewhere else and put a cap supplied on Subic. Do you know that not a...
    show more
  • joeldcndcn
    if you visit taipeh & seoul skorea and many US states and UK, they are using coal fired power plants but with very experienced/effective engineers who run those plants, resulting in good environmental friendly operations, ok? if certified filipino engineers have that experience & expertise in that field, the result...
    show more
  • Subic Bulletin
    So in the United states you say that the Coal Fired Power power plants are run by very experienced/effective engineers? But the United States spends 160 Billion on Heath Care as a result of operating Coal Fired Plants (Earth Institute Washington DC) so what your saying is if running a...
    show more
  • you have no idea about what you are talking about, I am in the power generation industry and even here in the US coal power plants are being shut down, cola as resource can not even be fully exploited here because it is very pollutive and nonrenewable
  • I guess you are correct with respect to coal power plants in the U.S. But in Europe, they are now using new technologies for clean coal-based power generation.
  • Clean Coal my friend is a Dirty Lie...all it can do is hide the smoke from us.....but in reality....once you burn something you throw something to the environment, seen or unseen, it is always harmful...to be exact, just try having a bbq using the ordinary coal at home....then DO ALL...
    show more
  • Subic Bulletin
    There is no such thing as "Clean Coal" it is just a marketing term for reduced pollution coal. How can you be fooled by the hype, fact is even developing countries like India and China are getting rid of coal!

No comments:

Post a Comment